Where to Stay in Nantucket: 7 Best Areas & Neighborhoods

Nantucket is a tiny island off the coast of the famous Cape Cod peninsula in Massachusetts. It was once the whaling capital of New England. The island welcomes summer visitors with its beaches and gray cedar-shingle buildings, which make it easy to envision the island’s distant past as a whaling hub in the 19th century.

Nantucket’s permanent population is around 14,000, but it grows significantly to over 80,000 in July and August when the island is most idyllic. Many Nantucket hotels reach maximum capacity in the summer.

With just 105 square miles of land, the island is swarming with visitors in the warm months, but this unique destination is a mandatory part of any Massachusetts vacation.

From the iconic lighthouse at Brant Point and the cobblestones of Main Street to the Cisco and Surfside surf culture, Nantucket squeezes quite a diverse array of environments into its tiny landmass. If New England were defined by one significant location, a picture of Nantucket’s iconic Main Street would undoubtedly qualify.

However, Nantucket has much more to offer, including some of New England’s best hotels, bed and breakfast establishments, and boutique hotels.

TL;DR: Top Picks for Accommodation

• Luxury Hotel – White Elephant Hotel
• Mid-Range Hotel – Nantucket Inn
• Budget Hotel – Martin House Inn
• Vacation Rental – Luxury Home with Pool
• Resort – The Wauwinet Nantucket

Our Favorite Areas to Stay in Nantucket

• For first-timers/tourists – Downtown Nantucket
• For luxury travelers – Wauwinet
• For families – Surfside
• For adventures – Tom Nevers
• For nightlife – Cisco
• For younger travelers – Madaket

Where to Stay on Nantucket Island

1. Downtown Nantucket

The area every first-time tourist will explore when they visit Nantucket, MA, is Downtown with the iconic Brant Point lighthouse and views of Nantucket Harbor. Downtown Nantucket (or just “Town”) sits along the island’s northern coastline, and the ferries that service the island arrive at the docks here, just south of the Brant Point Lighthouse. 

Downtown is where you’ll find most of the hotels, and it’s the best place to stay if it’s your first time on Nantucket. As you explore the Nantucket town center, you’ll notice fantastic historical preservation that makes every step feel like you’re walking through the pages of a storybook.

Wandering down the cobblestone streets means discovering pocket gardens brimming with roses, gazing upon the iconic gray-shingled cottages, and feeling like you’ve entered a time machine to the 19th century.

The town is where to stay in Nantucket for the first time, and the area is filled with historic inns like the Martin House Inn and the best boutique hotels like the Seven Sea Street Inn.

If all the walking around downtown makes your stomach grumble, consider having lunch or dinner at the Brant Point Grill in the White Elephant Hotel, one of the best Nantucket hotels. The restaurant and hotel are within walking distance of the Jethro Coffin house.

If you’ve never eaten fresh New England lobster, you might take the opportunity when you get a table at the Brant Point Grill. After eating, it’s time to relax on Children’s Beach, an ideal spot to play if you’re traveling with kids. It’s also the site of various recreational activities offered during the summer months. Children’s Beach is just around the corner from the White Elephant Hotel.

The Brass Lantern Inn is another Nantucket inn within easy walking distance of the beach. Here are some things to do in Downtown when you’re staying at a Nantucket hotel resort, inn, or vacation home:

• Main Street sightseeing
• Brant Point Lighthouse
• Jethro Coffin House
• Children’s Beach
• The Whaling Museum
• Antique fire truck ride

You’ll find most of the hotels in Nantucket in Town. The location is convenient to the entire island, so it’s possible to stay in town and reach every other area on day trips via ride-share, car rental, or bicycle.

Hotel guests in a Nantucket hotel or inn somewhere in Town usually get access to a complimentary breakfast, which is helpful when you’re aiming for an affordable Nantucket vacation.

It’s rare to find cheap hotels in Nantucket, but you will find more than one Nantucket hotel with helpful amenities to make your vacation easier. Here are some beautiful places to stay in Downtown Nantucket:

• Budget Hotel in Downtown: 21 Broad
• Mid-Range Hotel in Downtown: Martin House Inn
• Luxury Hotel in Downtown: White Elephant Nantucket
• Boutique Hotel in Downtown: Union Street Inn

See Related: Things to Do in Boston, Massachusetts

2. Siasconset Village (Sconset)

Siasconset Village is a little fishing village on the eastern edge of Nantucket Island, but nobody calls it by its full name. Instead, locals and travelers call it Sconset (Sconset). The village hasn’t changed much since the 1700s, when it started to become a popular place for vacations, fishing trips, and tiny Nantucket inns.

Yes, you read that right: people were vacationing in Sconset in the 1700s, and it remains one of the best areas to stay for excellent Nantucket hotel deals and vacation home stays.

The Sconset Bluff Walk is one of the best things to do when staying in the village. It was created by a resident in the late 1800s who wanted to ensure that visitors could always enjoy the beautiful views whether they resided in the village or were visiting it.

One of the village’s neat features is that most of the historic homes have the year they were built on a sign somewhere on the house. Many of the cottages also feature amusing nautical themes and characters.

It’s worth noting that most places to stay in Sconset are vacation homes rather than hotels. Most Sconset vacation homes offer all expected amenities, like a flat-screen TV and free Wi-Fi access. Renting a vacation home in Nantucket is an excellent way to get everyone their private bathroom, which is helpful when traveling in a group.

If you stroll far enough along the Sconset Bluff Walk, you’ll reach the Sankaty Head Lighthouse, which dates back to 1850. You’ll find a gift shop near the lighthouse if you’re itching for a nautical souvenir.

The lighthouse remains operational today but was automated in the 1960s, so you won’t find an old, crusty New England lighthouse keeper inside. Consider the following activities for your trip to Sconset:

• Sconset Bluff Walk
• Sankaty Head Lighthouse
• Ice cream at the Sconset Market
• Sconset Beach for seal-watching
• Siasconset Golf Course
• The Chanticleer Restaurant & Gardens

Sconset isn’t so much a town as a little village, so it’s an excellent place to stay in Nantucket when you want the bare minimum of neighbors and tourists around you during your stay. The closest you’ll get to a Nantucket hotel in Sconset is probably The Wade Cottages or The Summer House Cottages, which are collections of cottage-style rooms close to the ocean.

You’ll also find cute vacation rentals and cozy homes to rent for your stay in Nantucket. Here are a few options for your stay in Sconset:

• Budget Cottage in Sconset: Tiny House Cottage
• Mid-Range Cottage in Sconset: Roof Tree House
• Luxury House in Sconset: The Bounty

See Related: Things to Do in Salem, Massachusetts

3. Tom Nevers

Tom Never was a Wampanoag man born in Nantucket, MA, in the 1600s. Stories about him suggest that he was a whale watcher who searched the ocean from a high vantage point along the island’s southeast corner. The beach in the area, as well as a nearby swamp and a pond, were named after him.

At one time, the train depot that served the neighborhood was called “Tom Never’s Head,” but locals decided to shorten the name to Tom Nevers. During the summer, one of the best activities in Nantucket is sitting on the beach, and each beach around the island is a little different.

If you’re looking for a beach without huge crowds, you might take a picnic basket to Tom Nevers Beach to relax. On a cloudy day, the surf can get pretty raucous, so it’s best to keep to the sand and your beach chairs if you’re not an advanced swimmer. Here are some excellent activities in Tom Nevers:

• Tom Nevers Beach
• Nantucket Harvest Fair
• Tom Nevers Field
• Serengeti Nantucket Nature Preserve

You won’t find a traditional Nantucket hotel in Tom Nevers, but several beautiful vacation homes for rent. Some homes have ocean views, and most offer all the modern amenities you might want for your vacation.

Some luxury home rentals even come with a steam room and heated outdoor pool. For instance, a beautiful vacation home on Green Hollow Road has a pool. Positively, Paradise also has a swimming pool and a hot tub with convenient beach access. Consider the following places to stay in Tom Nevers:

• Budget Cottage in Tom Nevers: High Tide
• Mid-Range House in Tom Nevers: Nantucket Getaway
• Luxury House in Tom Nevers: Positively Paradise

See Related: Day Trips from Boston, Massachusetts

4. Surfside

If you’re traveling with young ones, Surfside is a fun and popular area to stay and explore for swimming and surfing. It’s definitely where to stay in Nantucket with kids. Surfside is ideal for groups who want to stay outside of Town and relax on some of the most entertaining beaches on the island but still have easy access to Town via bicycle, ride-share, bus, or car.

Since Nantucket is so small, it’s possible to visit without a car, and if you’re in reasonable shape, you can ride a bicycle from one side to the other in a day.

However, the Nantucket Regional Transit Authority (NRTA) runs a shuttle service that departs from the Town near Washington Street and the Union Street Inn.

Here are some activities for your family’s visit to Surfside:

• Surfside Beach
• Nantucket Ice Community Rink
• Fisherman’s Beach
• Nantucket Bake Shop
• Winter Park & Playground

Surfside is the most playful area of Nantucket with its popular beach, and you’ll find many vacation rentals at a variety of price points. If you think you’ll visit the beach often, try to get home just a short walk from the beach to avoid the hassles of parking. Here are a few places to stay in Surfside:

• Budget Stay in Surfside: Beautiful Custom One-Bedroom Apartment
• Mid-Range Cottage in Surfside: Beach Lover’s Dream
• Luxury House in Surfside: Stunning Surfside 6-Bedroom Estate

See Related: Things to Do in Pittsfield

5. Cisco

Cisco Beach and its neighborhood, which are west of Surfside, offer excellent activities for adults, like the very popular Cisco Brewers, where locals and travelers to Nantucket enjoy music and excellent craft beer in the outdoor courtyard. The property features a winery, distillery, and brewery, and there’s tons of outdoor seating for a chill and relaxed afternoon.

You don’t need to stay in Cisco to enjoy the brewery. If you’re staying at one of the Nantucket Resort Collection hotels, like Veranda House downtown, you’re just a few miles away from the brewery.

If you’re staying in a vacation home in Cisco near the island’s south side, you’re even closer. When you leave the brewery and after waiting about thirty minutes, jump into the surf and take a swim at Cisco Beach.

The beach is popular with surfers, and you can try your luck landing a wave or watch the surfers as you sit on the beach on a lazy summer day. The sunsets are spectacular at Cisco Beach, so it’s a great place to visit before you return to your cozy Nantucket inn or vacation home at the end of the day.

If you’re staying in a boutique hotel like Chapman House, don’t forget the beach towels and other seaworthy amenities that come with every room.

• Miacomet Golf Course
• Ladies Beach
• Cisco Brewers
• Surf at Cisco Beach
• Bartlett’s Farm

Cisco is an excellent place to stay when your main focus in Nantucket, MA, is visiting the beach during the day and spending your evenings enjoying a glass of craft beer. You’ll also find some beautiful vacation homes in Cisco that offer the perfect outdoor space for gatherings with a bottle of wine and good company.

Turn off the flat-screen TVs inside and head outdoors to the cozy deck with a view of the ocean. Here are a few places to stay in Cisco, Nantucket:

• Budget Cottage in Cisco: Upside Down Home with Ocean View
• Mid-Range House in Cisco: Cheerful Cisco Cottage
• Luxury House in Cisco: New Luxury Family Home

See Related: Best Islands in the US to Visit

6. Madaket

If you love nothing more than a glass of wine and a beautiful sunset, head to Madaket on the western side of Nantucket. This neighborhood offers a beautiful combination of wild, sandy beach trails, fun events for kids, and picturesque spots for picnics and sunsets.

It’s the best area to stay in Nantucket when you want an amazingly chill and relaxing vacation. Like the other communities outside of Town on Nantucket, Madaket is a peaceful area with bike paths, beach walks, and activities that younger travelers may enjoy.

If the allure of a remote, windswept beach on the Atlantic intrigues you, make an appointment with Madaket Beach. It’s a great place to watch the sunset, and the frequent winds are ideal for flying a kite. Just be aware of the rough surf.

Some serious waves often buffet the beach, so visiting during low tide is helpful. After your outing to the beach, try the ice cream or buttery lobster rolls at Millie’s Market. Then, take in the scenery on a bike ride on the 5-mile Madaket Bike Path. End your day with a beautiful sunset at Smith’s Point.

• Madaket Beach
• Millie’s Market
• Madaket Bike Path
• Smith’s Point

Many visitors stay in hotels in downtown Nantucket, then head to Madaket for day trips via the bus. Still, the neighborhood does feature several beautiful vacation rentals for those who want to stay outside of downtown and aren’t concerned with a hotel’s central location. Here are a few possibilities for your stay in Madaket:

• Budget Cottage in Madaket: Love Sand, Madaket on the Beach
• Mid-Range Cottage in Madaket: Scallop Oceanfront Cottage
• Luxury House in Madaket: Grey Seal Vacation Home

See Related: Cheap Places to Visit in the US

7. Wauwinet

Wauwinet sits at the northeast corner of Nantucket Island, and the area is where you’ll find the Nantucket hotel resort and landmark, The Wauwinet. If you’re looking for a hotel with perks like a private beach, fitness center, and luxurious rooms, stay at The Wauwinet, one of the best Nantucket hotels.

You’ll find most places to stay on the island near Nantucket’s historic district. Still, the Wauwinet is far outside of downtown, and it’s one of the best hotels on the island, with access to private beaches and some amazing amenities.

Guests have access to a full-service onsite spa. Don’t forget to go on a complimentary boat cruise during your stay. If you’re not a hotel guest, you can still take the boat cruise for a lunch or dinner reservation at Topper’s.

Traveling north along the small landmass that juts out from the island, you’ll reach Great Point Beach, the lighthouse, and the Nantucket National Wildlife Refuge. If the island’s west side offers the best sunsets, Wauwinet on the east side and its nearby beaches are your best option for beautiful sunrises.

You can reach the lighthouse on foot or by bicycle if you get a day pass at the nearby Coskata-Coatue Wildlife Refuge entrance gate. Some travelers head to the lighthouse in a Jeep or any vehicle with an Oversand Vehicle (OSV) permit.

• Great Point Lighthouse
• Boat Cruise from the White Elephant Hotel
• Nantucket Shipwreck and Life Saving Museum
• Coskata-Coatue Wildlife Refuge
• Great Point Beach

The Wauwinet Nantucket is definitely one of the premier Nantucket hotels in the area, but you’ll also find some vacation homes that range from cozy to extravagant. Here are a few of the best hotels and residences to consider in the Wauwinet area:

• Budget Cottage in Wauwinet: Cachalot
• Mid-Range House in Wauwinet: Lockup Beach House
• Luxury Hotel in Wauwinet: The Wauwinet Nantucket

FAQ

Related Resources

• Islands to Visit Around the World
• Ways to Book an Around the World Ticket
• Most Haunted Hotels in Salem, Massachusetts